Milwaukee won it all on less than half Philly's payroll. The Phillies' staff led MLB in WAR. Their bats and gloves finished at or near the bottom.
On Wednesday night, the Milwaukee Brewers beat Tampa Bay 4-1 in Game 5 and won the first World Series title in franchise history, per AP. They won 103 games, the most in MLB, and swept the Dodgers in the NLCS.
The Phillies spent Oct. 1 losing a Wild Card Series to Atlanta.
Now the money. According to AP's Opening Day payroll study, the Phillies carried $282.0 million, fourth in MLB, while Milwaukee carried $124.1 million. That's 44 cents on the dollar, and the 44-cent team has the trophy. The dollar team has a long winter and a lot of explaining to do about where that money went.
Here's the Phillies' October since 2022, per Baseball-Reference: lost the World Series, lost the NLCS, lost the NLDS, lost the NLDS, lost the Wild Card Series. Every October has ended at the same round or earlier than the one before. MLB.com called this their earliest exit in five years.
It wasn't the pitching. By Baseball-Reference's pitching WAR, which adjusts for park and the defense behind the pitchers, the Phillies' staff was the best in baseball at 31.1. The staff is the one part Dave Dombrowski's roster got right.
It was everything else. The Phillies' team OPS+ was 89, 30th of 30, and their hitters combined for 5.4 WAR, also last. Bryce Harper (131 OPS+) and Kyle Schwarber (128) were the only everyday players above league average, per MLB.com and B-Ref. Trea Turner posted an 81 and J.T. Realmuto a 65. The gloves didn't help: minus-48 Defensive Runs Saved, 28th. FanGraphs' Jay Jaffe rated them the worst defense among playoff teams, same as in 2023 and 2025. MLB.com's Phillies reporters say the offense, defense and bullpen all finished in the bottom third. The bullpen part is a squeaker: a 4.43 ERA, 21st of 30, by MLB's stats feed. The offense and defense parts are not.
The 88 wins flatter them, too. They started 9-19, which cost Rob Thomson his job on April 28. Under Don Mattingly they went 79-55, the fourth-best record in baseball over that stretch. Mattingly has since signed through 2028. A 713-698 run margin makes them an 83-79 Pythagorean team, by B-Ref's math. They were fine, then lucky, then gone.
Dombrowski, at his end-of-season press conference: "I've created this situation, right?" He was talking about a high payroll with little wiggle room. MLB.com reports he doesn't plan to trade Harper, Schwarber, Turner or Realmuto, who have full no-trade rights anyway.
Now Milwaukee. This is not a farm-system fairy tale. CBS Sports counted 12 homegrown players on the Brewers' 40-man roster versus 11 for the Phillies. It counted 22 trade acquisitions versus 15, and 3 free agents versus 8. Sporting News broke down the 26-man World Series roster: 8 drafted, 4 signed as amateurs and 14 acquired by trade. The only major-league free agent on it was Gary Sánchez, at $1.75 million.
So the Brewers didn't win by growing everyone. They won by finding the right guys. William Contreras, the World Series MVP, arrived in the three-team Sean Murphy trade with Atlanta and Oakland. Jake Bauers and Trevor Megill came in minor deals. Jacob Misiorowski was a second-round pick out of a junior college. Cooper Pratt, a sixth-rounder, had two hits and two RBIs in the clincher, per AP.
And they built a lineup with a plan. MLB.com's Todd Zolecki noted that Milwaukee chased the fewest pitches in baseball (26.9%) while the Phillies ranked fourth in chase rate (32.6%), then went to 36.9% against Atlanta. The Brewers' 832 runs were second in MLB, their .341 OBP first, and their bullpen's 3.40 ERA third. They were also third in Defensive Runs Saved at plus-55.
Be careful with the lesson, though. One title doesn't prove money is dead. And you can't just copy Milwaukee when the 2027 plan is a locked-in core, a new hitting coach and a better backup catcher, per MLB.com. The old one, Garrett Stubbs, is being designated for assignment, the Inquirer reported Thursday, after he and Rafael Marchán combined for a .316 OPS.
The Phillies didn't lose because they had stars. They lost because the money went to a roster that couldn't hit or field, and the one group that did its job couldn't carry it alone. Milwaukee spent less, got on base, caught the ball and kept the late innings boring. Philadelphia spent $282 million on name recognition. Turns out boring was the one thing nobody thought to buy.
Bob Boone has died at 78, confirmed by his son Bret. He caught Tug McGraw's series-ending strikeout of Willie Wilson in Game 6 of the 1980 World Series, and he hit .412 in that Series, 7-for-17, with no strikeouts. A Philadelphia remembrance of the catcher behind that last pitch, the first title, and a three-generation baseball family.
Turner has $190.9 million left and a full no-trade clause. Marsh is the only one who can actually move.
Ken Rosenthal reported the only condition under which Harper would waive his no-trade clause: a new team extending him past 2031, into his forties. Five straight playoff exits have this town dreaming big. The math has other ideas.
Jhoan Duran threw a 1.82 ERA with 33 saves for the Phillies in 2026. Baseball-Reference has him free-agent eligible after 2027. That's one arbitration season of club control left, and every multi-year pitch sits under a Dec. 1 CBA clock.
Comments
Loading comments...